Revising Britain’s Libel Laws.

The petition has been approved and is ready to be signed – just follow the link…

http://petitions.pm.gov.uk/libellaws/ (it does help if I put the bloody link in as well)

To be clear about what kind of things I am advocating when I suggest that we adopt US-style libel laws.

A reversal of the existing presumption of guilt and burden of proof in libel, such the plaintiff is required to demonstrate that that they have been libelled. At present, the plaintiff in a libel action has only to prove only that the defendent made the allegedly libellous statement, from which point it is the defendent who must supply proof that the statement is not libellous.

The inclusion of the US provisions that hold that a public figure may be held to have been libelled only where the libellous statement was made with what, in the US, is refered to as ‘actual malice’, i.e. that it was made knowing it to be false or with reckless disregard for the truth.

THe inclusion of a form of ‘Common Carrier’ status for blog owners, online forums, etc., i.e. a blogger or forum owner may not be held liable for libellous comments posted on their by a third party provided that they act reasonably on receiving a complaint that such a comment constitutes a libel.

And end to the ‘viral’ nature of libel in the UK, in which every publication of a defamatory statement gives rise to a separate claim. US law permits only a single claim for primary publication.

7 Comments
Better to write on your knees then get sued on your feet?

The decision by blogger Jackie Danicki to publish a photograph of a man she alleges to have assaulted her on a tube train (Jackie’s site is down at present, so no direct link) and request help in identifying her attacker appears to have prompted the usual bout of harumphing from one of two journalists about the ‘ethical standards‘ of… - Continue Reading...

4 Comments
Tough on the causes of crime?

Having a background in psychology, I should be entirely comfortable with the outcome of a new criminological study into street crime that demonstrates that the underlying motives for such crime can be rather more complex than mere acquisition.

And yet, instead, I find myself unable to shake the mental picture of Tony Blair striding purposefully into the Cabinet Room, research paper in hand,… - Continue Reading...

2 Comments
Corruption: Its in the national interest…

I’ve seen some excuses in my time but the latest from the ongoing Serious Fraud Office investigation into BAE’s dealings with the Saudi’s take the absolute biscuit:

Secret payments of millions of pounds from Britain’s biggest arms company have been found in Swiss accounts linked to Wafic Said, a billionaire arms broker for the Saudi Royal family, according to legal sources.

Mr Said refused last

- Continue Reading...

3 Comments
Archives
Recent Comments
Recommended
Science/Skepticism
Politics
Ministry of Truth RSS 2.0
Ministry of Truth - Twitter
  • If New Labour is dead – what replaces it? September 2, 2010
    Sunder and Left Futures do a good job of rebutting Blair’s claim that Labour lost the election because it was insufficiently New Labour. But there’s something to add. […]
    Chris Dillow
  • In 2010, Tony Blair was so unpopular that… September 2, 2010
    […]
    Don Paskini
  • Will the web always be a hive for conspiracy theories? September 2, 2010
    On Sunday, Demos released a report, The Power of Unreason. We looked at the role conspiracy theories play in extremism, violence, and terrorism. Extremist groups use conspiracy theories to recruit, to justify violent acts and to maintain an ideology that sees violence as the answer to the world they find themselves within. Conspiracy theories can therefore b […]
    Guest
  • Theories: Splitting Linguistic Hairs and the Work of Anne Elk (Miss) August 29, 2010
    The work of Anne Elk (Miss), undoubtedly one of the overlooked intellectual giants of our age, serves to remind us of the importance of theories. And indeed, how anyone can hold one … ahem! I cannot gainsay Miss Elk’s evident expertise in the area of paleantology since I know nothing of Brontosauruses. But I was fascinated to hear the ‘T’ word occur […]
    Jourdemayne
  • Middle Age Spread August 29, 2010
    Once again, there are stories in the press about the rise of Sexually Transmitted Infections (STIs) in young people (under 24), with half a million new cases in the UK in the last year, a rise of 3% from the 2008 figures. There's an excellent analysis of the data and the media response by Dr Petra Boynton who also deals adeptly with an ill-informed resp […]
    Tessera
  • Amateaur astronomers discovery rotating pulsar using Arecibo August 25, 2010
    [2:07 begins the commentary by the discoverers] READ MORE read more […]
    Casey