Telegraph can’t do stats…

Oh dear, it seems the Daily Telegraph needs a refresher course in statistics…

More than one crime in five in London is now committed by a foreign national, raising fresh fears over the impact of immigration.

Around a third of all sex offences and a half of all frauds in the capital are carried out by non-British citizens.

Poles, who have entered Britain in record numbers since they joined the European Union in 2004, committed 2,310 crimes in the first six months of this year to become the most prolific offenders.

Romanians, whose country became part of the EU in January, committed more than 1,000 offences — an eightfold rise on the same period in 2006, according to Metropolitan Police figures for solved crimes.

Ah, look, this is the data for ‘solved crimes’ not all crime, i.e. that committed and reported but not solved, so immediately these figures are questionable. It could be that foreign nationals are committing lots of crimes, or it could be simply that the Met is particularly good at solving crimes committed by foreign nationals, which could mean that these crimes get extra resources or that there’s just a smaller pool of potential criminals to target and that their nationality narrows the field down even further.

To ‘help’ matters, the Telegraph chucks in a Daily Mail-style table of the ‘worst offenders’…

ncrime123.gif

And now the problems with this data becomes even more apparent, especially if you start comparing this table to the Met’s own crime figures.

So, for violent crimes, the top twenty list above weigh in with a total of 3812 offences, while the Met’s rolling 12 month figures give a total of 172,734 violent offences from March 07 to March 08 (down 5.3% on the previous years. As we’re only dealing a half year’s figures (and ignoring seasonal variations for ease) that gives us 86,387 violent offences of which these top twenty account for under 5%. So its not 1 in 5, its about 1 in 20.

Of course, this doesn’t include crimes committed by foreign national which aren’t solved, but if the Telegraph can compare apples and oranges to make its point, then so can I to show that their figures are a crock of shit.

Sex Offences? Full year is 8766, so a half year is 4383 and our top twenty weighs in with 263, and we have a figure of 6% and not a third as the Telegraph claims.

Theft and handling is a little tricker – the Met gives figures for burglary and robbery but doesn’t mention handling, while the Telgraph’s copy leads on fraud, which isn’t mentioned at all in either their table or the Met’s stats.

Still, we get, from our top twenty table, 3637 solved crimes while burglaries alone run to 93,894 a year, so that’s 46947 for the half year and a figure of just under 8%, which will almost certainly fall once handling offences are factored in on top.

(via)

19 Comments
If the shots get any cheaper…

It seems that Iain Dale is getting in on the who’s flying what where angle, even if his efforts, like those of his oppo, Shane Greer, are actually pretty risible:

Journalists were quick to point out that instead of flying on a British Airways jet decorated with the Union Flag, the Prime Minister hired a charter jet, decorated with stars more akin to

- Continue Reading...

4 Comments
You Shall Not Bear False Witness

As this recent missive from Nadine Dorries, the MP for Mid-Narnia, has gone rather unnoticed, despite its unremitting stupidity, then I guess it fall to me to pick it to pieces.

New figures will be officially released next week which will claim that there is no need to reduce the upper limit at which abortion takes place from 24 to 20

- Continue Reading...

4 Comments
Archives
Recent Comments
Recommended
Science/Skepticism
Politics
Ministry of Truth RSS 2.0
Ministry of Truth - Twitter
  • If New Labour is dead – what replaces it? September 2, 2010
    Sunder and Left Futures do a good job of rebutting Blair’s claim that Labour lost the election because it was insufficiently New Labour. But there’s something to add. […]
    Chris Dillow
  • In 2010, Tony Blair was so unpopular that… September 2, 2010
    […]
    Don Paskini
  • Will the web always be a hive for conspiracy theories? September 2, 2010
    On Sunday, Demos released a report, The Power of Unreason. We looked at the role conspiracy theories play in extremism, violence, and terrorism. Extremist groups use conspiracy theories to recruit, to justify violent acts and to maintain an ideology that sees violence as the answer to the world they find themselves within. Conspiracy theories can therefore b […]
    Guest
  • Theories: Splitting Linguistic Hairs and the Work of Anne Elk (Miss) August 29, 2010
    The work of Anne Elk (Miss), undoubtedly one of the overlooked intellectual giants of our age, serves to remind us of the importance of theories. And indeed, how anyone can hold one … ahem! I cannot gainsay Miss Elk’s evident expertise in the area of paleantology since I know nothing of Brontosauruses. But I was fascinated to hear the ‘T’ word occur […]
    Jourdemayne
  • Middle Age Spread August 29, 2010
    Once again, there are stories in the press about the rise of Sexually Transmitted Infections (STIs) in young people (under 24), with half a million new cases in the UK in the last year, a rise of 3% from the 2008 figures. There's an excellent analysis of the data and the media response by Dr Petra Boynton who also deals adeptly with an ill-informed resp […]
    Tessera
  • Amateaur astronomers discovery rotating pulsar using Arecibo August 25, 2010
    [2:07 begins the commentary by the discoverers] READ MORE read more […]
    Casey